• About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Thursday, November 19, 2026
No Result
View All Result
CNI
Subscribe
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
      • Economy
      • Technology
    • Capitol Briefs
    • Courts
      • Law Enforcement
    • Corruption Cases
      • Madigan Trial
        • Michael Madigan: The Rise and Fall
        • Madigan Trial in Review
      • ComEd 4 Trial
      • Emil Jones Trial
      • Paul La Schiazza Trial
      • Sam McCann Trial
      • Tim Mapes Trial
      • James Weiss Trial
    • Education
    • Environment
      • Agriculture
      • Energy
    • Government
      • Budget
      • Health
      • Immigration
      • Infrastructure
    • Healing Illinois
  • Investigations
    • Police Hiring
    • No Schoolers
    • Funeral Home
    • Culture of Cruelty
  • Elections
    • Election Guide
    • Midterm Results
  • CNI Insider
  • Podcasts
  • About Us
    • The News Team
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Privacy
    • Terms
  • Media Center
    • Pressroom
    • Republish Guidelines
    • Press Releases
    • Editorial Independence
    • Conflicts of Interest
    • Code of Ethics
    • AI Policy
    • Submit News Tip
    • Contact
  • Support Us
    • Support
    • Donors
CNI

CHARLIE WHEELER: Is Pritzker tax plan a good way to reallocate wealth in Illinois?

CNI ContributorbyCNI Contributor
August 17, 2019
in Government
A A
Charlie Wheeler

Charlie Wheeler

354
VIEWS
FacebookShareReddit

By CHARLIE WHEELER, Former Director, Public Affairs Reporting Program, University of Illinois Springfield

Gov. J. B. Pritzker has proposed a graduated income tax for Illinois (higher rates for higher incomes), which prompts these fundamental questions: How should society allocate wealth? How should government redistribute it? And, of course, should we vote for or against the graduated tax at the 2020 election? (Whew, talk about big topics for 800 words!)

Life is, at the core, about the struggle for wealth and power. I tell my students that political science is the study of who gets what, why, and how?

Kings and rulers used to allocate wealth by taking as much of it as they could for themselves without fomenting peasant revolts. Uprisings in the medieval centuries by charismatic peasant leaders like Wat Tyler in England usually ended with guys like Wat and his followers dangling from gibbets. Those with the wealth (known otherwise as power) generally prevailed.

Plagues in the same period wiped big chunks of the peasantry off the countryside, which increased demand for the remaining workers — and thus wages. So, the market plays a role, though imperfectly.

Enlightenment thinkers of the 17th Century proposed that people other than royalty should have a say in budgeting and taxation; the idea took hold in England and here.

allwyn allwyn allwyn
ADVERTISEMENT

So, today in the U.S., capital (the wealthy) and labor duke it out for bigger shares of wealth in the marketplace as well as in government taxation and distribution policies. Though we have graduated income tax rates at the national level, the rich seem to be getting a lot richer, and the poor, poorer. Not good.

Which brings me to the question of how should wealth be allocated? I have thought that wealth should ideally be distributed on the basis of how much value a person adds to society, in both the short and long term.

I have a friend who is a world-renowned scientist at the Mayo Clinics in Minnesota. Her discoveries over the years continue to save lives. She is well-paid but, to my mind, should be among the very top earners, based on the value she has added. I also think, for example, that plumbers and those who maintain our sanitation and drinking water systems should be even better paid than they are.

On the other hand, I think the high-flying financiers who brought the world economy to its knees a few years back, with their greed-driven mortgage fraud, should be stripped of their wealth, instead of getting off scot-free as they did.

I’ll bet readers have their own lists of who should be better and lesser compensated. But as you can see, such “analysis” of who should get what doesn’t even rise to the level of loosey-goosey.

Government, which is to represent our collective thinking, began redistributing wealth with land grants to veterans of our Revolution. In 2017, John F. Cogan authored a well-researched book about government redistribution of wealth. He found that today 41 percent of nonelderly-headed households, from single mothers to farmers and many others, receive entitlement benefits. Three-fifths of all children are growing up in families that receive some government assistance.

Support Us Support Us Support Us
ADVERTISEMENT

Ironically, if we gave nearly all wealth just to those who add value, our economy would collapse. That is, the many of us who don’t add much value would lack the money to buy the technology and other non-essential doo-dads produced with the capital owned largely by the wealthy.

So, back to Pritzker’s proposal to tax more heavily those with $250,000 plus in annual income. If I were selfish, I would say, let’s do it, as my central Illinois home area would be a big beneficiary. Most of the increase in tax revenue would come from Chicago and the suburbs. That is where most high-earners reside, and much of the revenue would end up in school aid and social programs for downstate. (The “separatists” of the moment, who would strip Chicagoland from the state, are true know-nothings. Much as I hate to admit it, the northeast of Illinois supports the rest of the state big time through the redistribution of tax revenue.)

I have no issue with graduated rates per se; my problem is that taxing high-income value-adders and job creators more than the rest of us might result in net negative economic consequences for our state. Illinois already has a poor perceived business climate — high taxes, especially property taxes; corruption; more regulations than competitor states like Texas and Florida. Thus, imposing even more taxation on the creator class, which can create wherever it wants, might cause increased flight from our state.

Based on what I sense at the moment, I would vote against the Pritzker proposal. I am, however, reaching out to economist friends on this issue. Maybe they will convince me otherwise. We should all stay tuned to the arguments pro and con that will fill the media over the coming year.

Jim Nowlan is a retired professor, former state legislator and senior aide to three unindicted governors. He is president of Stark County Communications, a member of the Illinois Press Association. He can be reached at jnowlan3@gmail.com.

Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service that distributes state government coverage to hundreds of news outlets statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation.
Insider Insider Insider
ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: Governmentsort
CNI Contributor

CNI Contributor

CNI ContributorCapitol News Illinois is a nonprofit news service operated by the Illinois Press Foundation that provides coverage of state government to newspapers, broadcast outlets and other media throughout Illinois.

Related Posts

gambling addiction hotline billboard

Illinois offers ‘fragmented’ response to gambling addiction, internal state report says

November 18, 2026
460
Carol Ammons and Aaron Ammons

House committee investigating Rep. Carol Ammons to move forward with witnesses

November 17, 2026
619

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Republish this article

Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

When republishing or co-publishing our stories, please copy and paste our tracking code (found at the bottom of the copy below - it includes the words "republication-tracker-tool") anywhere in the body of this article in your website’s content management system. This will let us know how much traffic our story has received. Republishing Guidelines.

CHARLIE WHEELER: Is Pritzker tax plan a good way to reallocate wealth in Illinois?

by CNI Contributor, Capitol News Illinois
August 17, 2019

Insider Insider Insider
Capitol News Illinois
2501 Chatham Road, Suite 200
Springfield, IL 62704
editors@capitolnewsillinois.com
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service covering state government. A service of the Illinois Press Foundation.

SubscribeMore news from the Illinois
Statehouse delivered to your
inbox.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms

© 2026 Capitol News Illinois

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
      • Economy
      • Technology
    • Capitol Briefs
    • Courts
      • Corruption Cases
      • Law Enforcement
    • Environment
      • Agriculture
      • Energy
    • Government
      • Budget
      • Education
      • Health
      • Immigration
      • Infrastructure
    • Healing Illinois
  • Investigations
    • Police Hiring
    • No Schoolers
    • Funeral Home
    • Culture of Cruelty
  • Elections
    • Election Guide
    • Midterm Results
  • CNI Insider
  • Podcasts
  • About
  • Media
  • Support
  • Subscribe

© 2026 Capitol News Illinois