• About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Saturday, November 21, 2026
No Result
View All Result
CNI
Subscribe
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
      • Economy
      • Technology
    • Capitol Briefs
    • Courts
      • Law Enforcement
    • Corruption Cases
      • Madigan Trial
        • Michael Madigan: The Rise and Fall
        • Madigan Trial in Review
      • ComEd 4 Trial
      • Emil Jones Trial
      • Paul La Schiazza Trial
      • Sam McCann Trial
      • Tim Mapes Trial
      • James Weiss Trial
    • Education
    • Environment
      • Agriculture
      • Energy
    • Government
      • Budget
      • Health
      • Immigration
      • Infrastructure
    • Healing Illinois
  • Investigations
    • Police Hiring
    • No Schoolers
    • Funeral Home
    • Culture of Cruelty
  • Elections
    • Election Guide
    • Midterm Results
  • CNI Insider
  • Podcasts
  • About Us
    • The News Team
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Privacy
    • Terms
  • Media Center
    • Pressroom
    • Republish Guidelines
    • Press Releases
    • Editorial Independence
    • Conflicts of Interest
    • Code of Ethics
    • AI Policy
    • Submit News Tip
    • Contact
  • Support Us
    • Support
    • Donors
CNI

Attorney: Back pay due to all lawmakers who served between 2009 and 2018

Former legislators who filed suit say comptroller obligated to pay wages lost to freezes, furloughs

Rebecca AnzelbyRebecca Anzel
September 14, 2019
in Government
A A
James Clyborne and Michael Noland

Former state Sens. James Clyborne (left) and Michael Noland (right). Credits: senatorclayborne.com and Wikipedia

2.4k
VIEWS
FacebookShareReddit

SPRINGFIELD — Illinois’ chief fiscal officer has a “clear duty” to pay lost wages to all members of the General Assembly affected by two statutes a Cook County judge ruled were unconstitutional, the attorney for two former Democratic state senators wrote in a court filing.

One law freezing cost-of-living increases and another implementing furlough days violated Illinois’ governing document because they altered legislators’ wages during terms for which they were elected, Circuit Court Judge Franklin Valderrama decided in July.

Now, two former lawmakers who voted in favor of both statutes — Michael Noland, from Elgin, and James Clayborne, Jr., from Belleville — are asking the judge to compel Comptroller Susana Mendoza to issue back pay. If successful, the order could cost Illinois just under $13 million.

Noland is now a judge in Kane County. Clayborne is a privately-practicing lawyer.

Michael Scotti III, their attorney from the Chicago-based firm Roetzell & Andress, sent a letter in late July asking the comptroller to begin releasing payments. It went unanswered, he wrote in a court document.

In the letter, he argued that because the two laws were deemed to violate Illinois’ Constitution, “the comptroller is obligated to pay the members of the General Assembly during the relevant years, including [Noland and Clayborne], the salary unconstitutionally withheld for the furlough days and the COLAs.”

allwyn allwyn allwyn
ADVERTISEMENT

The former was effective from 2009 through 2013 and the latter from July 2009 through June 2018.

A legislator’s base pay was $67,836 until this year, when the General Assembly allowed the first cost-of-living increase to go into effect since 2008. That salary increased by $1,600.

The attorney general’s office argued in a court document last month, in part, that Mendoza should not have to pay Noland, Clayborne or any other lawmaker back pay because next fiscal year’s budgeting process is complete and no funding has been allocated for that expense.

“Contrary to statements that have been made in the press, the comptroller can — and in fact is obligated to — make these payments regardless of whether the General Assembly has specifically appropriated money for this purpose,” according to the letter Scotti sent.

The state is also arguing Noland and Clayborne’s voting history — each “voted repeatedly in support” of the pay freezes and furlough days, according to court documents — absolves Mendoza of the need to pay the former legislators.

The two supported the laws Valderrama ruled were unconstitutional “fourteen separate times over the course of nine years,” the document states.

Support Us Support Us Support Us
ADVERTISEMENT

“I think the arguments have just begun over whether legislators can make big election-year speeches about voting to turn down a raise, issue re-election news releases touting their selflessness in turning down a raise; then years later shamelessly file a lawsuit to force taxpayers to retroactively pay them $10 million for raises they turned down to get re-elected,” Mendoza said in an emailed statement. “These hypocrites don’t deserve a penny.”

The next court hearing is scheduled for Oct. 15.

Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service that distributes state government coverage to hundreds of news outlets statewide. It is funded primarily by the Illinois Press Foundation and the Robert R. McCormick Foundation.
Insider Insider Insider
ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: Governmentsort
Rebecca Anzel

Rebecca Anzel

ReporterRebecca Anzel was one of the first three reporters hired at Capitol News Illinois in January 2019. She worked at CNI until September 2020.

Related Posts

gambling addiction hotline billboard

Illinois offers ‘fragmented’ response to gambling addiction, internal state report says

November 18, 2026
577
Carol Ammons and Aaron Ammons

House committee investigating Rep. Carol Ammons to move forward with witnesses

November 17, 2026
976

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Republish this article

Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

When republishing or co-publishing our stories, please copy and paste our tracking code (found at the bottom of the copy below - it includes the words "republication-tracker-tool") anywhere in the body of this article in your website’s content management system. This will let us know how much traffic our story has received. Republishing Guidelines.

Attorney: Back pay due to all lawmakers who served between 2009 and 2018

by Rebecca Anzel, Capitol News Illinois
September 14, 2019

Insider Insider Insider
Capitol News Illinois
2501 Chatham Road, Suite 200
Springfield, IL 62704
editors@capitolnewsillinois.com
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan news service covering state government. A service of the Illinois Press Foundation.

SubscribeMore news from the Illinois
Statehouse delivered to your
inbox.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms

© 2026 Capitol News Illinois

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Business
      • Economy
      • Technology
    • Capitol Briefs
    • Courts
      • Corruption Cases
      • Law Enforcement
    • Environment
      • Agriculture
      • Energy
    • Government
      • Budget
      • Education
      • Health
      • Immigration
      • Infrastructure
    • Healing Illinois
  • Investigations
    • Police Hiring
    • No Schoolers
    • Funeral Home
    • Culture of Cruelty
  • Elections
    • Election Guide
    • Midterm Results
  • CNI Insider
  • Podcasts
  • About
  • Media
  • Support
  • Subscribe

© 2026 Capitol News Illinois